lp smartside vs hardie

LP Smartside vs Hardie Siding: Choosing The Best For You

Two of the most prominent options for siding your home are LP Smartside and Hardie Siding. Both offer robust, durable solutions that promise to enhance your home’s curb appeal while providing long-lasting protection. However, deciding between the two can be challenging, as each has its unique strengths and potential drawbacks. In this article, we’ll compare LP Smartside vs Hardie Siding, including:

  • Overview of LP Smartside and Hardie Siding
  • Durability and resistance
  • Aesthetics and design options
  • Installation process
  • Maintenance requirements
  • Cost considerations
  • Environmental impact
  • Warranty and support
  • Climate considerations
  • Resale value
  • A summary of the pros and cons of each
  • Final tips for homeowners

🤔 Comparing Hardie Siding and LP Smartside

When considering materials for home exterior siding, Hardie Siding and LP Smartside are two popular options. This section will compare these two types of siding, including their durability, cost, aesthetic appeal, and more.

1. Overview of Hardie Siding and LP Smartside

Hardie Siding: Hardie Siding, also known as James Hardie Siding or Hardie Board, is made from fiber cement, a combination of cellulose fibers, cement, and sand. It’s renowned for its durability, resistance to fire, pests, and extreme weather conditions. Hardie Siding can mimic the look of wood, stucco, or even shingles, providing various aesthetic options.

LP Smartside: LP Smartside is an engineered wood siding product made from wood strands coated with a resin binder and compressed to create a strong board. The product is then treated with a proprietary SmartGuard process that incorporates zinc borate for added protection against termites and fungal decay. LP Smartside is known for its natural wood appearance and versatility.

2. Durability and Resistance

Hardie Siding Durability: Hardie Siding’s fiber cement composition gives it superior resistance to fire, pests, and rot. It performs exceptionally well in extreme weather conditions, including high heat, humidity, and freezing temperatures. Its non-combustible nature adds an extra layer of safety, particularly important in fire-prone areas.

LP Smartside Durability: LP Smartside is engineered to withstand various environmental challenges. The SmartGuard treatment ensures resistance to termites and fungal decay. However, as an engineered wood product, it is more susceptible to moisture damage than fiber cement. Proper installation and maintenance are crucial to prevent moisture-related issues like warping or swelling.

3. Aesthetics and Design Options

Hardie Siding Aesthetics: Hardie Siding also offers a wide array of styles, textures, and colors. It can replicate the look of wood, stucco, or shingles, allowing for diverse architectural expressions. Hardie’s ColorPlus Technology provides baked-on finishes that resist fading and chipping, ensuring long-lasting color retention and minimal maintenance.

LP Smartside Aesthetics: LP Smartside is highly regarded for its authentic wood appearance. It comes in various styles, including lap siding, shakes, and panels, offering a versatile range of design options. The texture and finish can closely mimic traditional wood siding, making it an attractive choice for homeowners seeking a classic, natural look.

4. Installation Process

Hardie Siding Installation: Hardie Siding’s fiber cement composition makes it heavier and more challenging to work with compared to engineered wood. Installation typically requires specialized tools and expertise, potentially increasing labor costs and time. However, professional installation ensures that the siding’s durability and performance are maximized.

LP Smartside Installation: LP Smartside is lighter and easier to cut than fiber cement, making the installation process relatively straightforward. It can be worked with standard woodworking tools, which can reduce labor costs and installation time. However, precise installation is vital to avoid moisture intrusion and ensure longevity.

5. Maintenance Requirements

Hardie Siding Maintenance: Hardie Siding is relatively low-maintenance due to its durable fiber cement composition. The ColorPlus Technology finish requires less frequent painting, and the siding’s resistance to pests, rot, and weather damage reduces the need for repairs. Routine cleaning and occasional inspections are typically sufficient to keep Hardie Siding in excellent condition.

LP Smartside Maintenance: LP Smartside requires regular maintenance to preserve its appearance and performance. This includes periodic painting or staining, as the finish can fade over time. It’s also important to inspect for any signs of moisture damage, especially in areas with high humidity or rainfall.

6. Cost Considerations

Hardie Siding Cost: Hardie Siding tends to have a higher initial cost due to its fiber cement composition and the need for specialized installation. However, its durability and low maintenance requirements can offset these initial expenses. The longer lifespan and minimal upkeep can make Hardie Siding a cost-effective investment in the long run.

LP Smartside Cost: LP Smartside is generally more affordable upfront than Hardie Siding. The lower cost of materials, coupled with easier installation, can make it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. However, long-term maintenance costs should be considered, as regular painting and potential repairs can add up over time.

7. Environmental Impact

Hardie Siding Environmental Impact: Hardie Siding is made from sustainable raw materials, including cement and cellulose fibers. Its long lifespan and low maintenance requirements contribute to a lower environmental footprint. Additionally, James Hardie has committed to environmentally friendly manufacturing processes, further enhancing the product’s sustainability.

LP Smartside Environmental Impact: LP Smartside is made from renewable wood resources, and the manufacturing process incorporates sustainable practices. The product’s longevity and durability also contribute to its environmental credentials. However, the need for regular maintenance and repainting may slightly offset these benefits.

8. Warranty and Support

Hardie Siding Warranty: Hardie Siding comes with a 30-year non-prorated warranty, which provides comprehensive coverage for defects in materials and workmanship. The ColorPlus Technology finish is also backed by a 15-year limited warranty against chipping, peeling, and fading. These robust warranties provide homeowners with significant peace of mind.

LP Smartside Warranty: LP Smartside offers a limited warranty of up to 50 years, reflecting the company’s confidence in the product’s durability. This warranty covers manufacturing defects and is prorated over time. Proper installation and maintenance are necessary to uphold the warranty terms.

9. Climate Considerations

Hardie Siding in Various Climates: Hardie Siding’s fiber cement composition makes it an excellent choice for harsh climates, including areas with extreme heat, cold, or humidity. Its resistance to fire, pests, and rot ensures reliable performance in diverse weather conditions. Homeowners in coastal areas also benefit from Hardie’s resistance to salt air corrosion.

LP Smartside in Various Climates: LP Smartside performs well in a variety of climates, but it’s particularly suited for regions with moderate weather conditions. In areas with high humidity or frequent rainfall, extra care must be taken during installation to prevent moisture-related issues. Regular maintenance is crucial in such environments to ensure long-term performance.

10. Resale Value

Hardie Siding Resale Value: Hardie Siding is known to boost a home’s resale value significantly. Its reputation for durability, low maintenance, and aesthetic versatility appeals to prospective buyers. The presence of Hardie Siding can be a strong selling point, particularly in regions prone to extreme weather or where fire resistance is a concern.

LP Smartside Resale Value: LP Smartside can enhance a home’s resale value by providing a visually appealing, durable exterior. The natural wood look is particularly attractive to potential buyers. However, the long-term value depends on proper maintenance and the condition of the siding at the time of sale.

⚖️ Pros and Cons Summary

lp smartside vs hardie

✅ LP Smartside Pros:

  • Authentic wood appearance
  • Easier and less expensive installation

🚫 LP Smartside Cons:

  • Higher susceptibility to moisture damage
  • Requires regular maintenance (painting/staining)
  • Less fire-resistant compared to fiber cement

✅ Hardie Siding Pros:

  • Exceptional durability and weather resistance
  • Fire-resistant and non-combustible
  • Low maintenance with long-lasting finishes
  • Wide range of design options

🚫 Hardie Siding Cons:

  • More complex and costly installation
  • Heavier material requiring specialized tools

💡 Final Tips for Homeowners

lp smartside vs hardie

Choosing the right siding for your home is a significant decision that can impact its appearance and value for years to come. Here are some final considerations to help you make an informed choice.

  • Research and Planning: Take the time to research both siding options thoroughly. Look at customer reviews, speak with contractors, and visit homes with LP Smartside or Hardie Siding installed to see how they perform in real-world conditions.
  • Professional Consultation: Engage with professional siding installers who have experience with both products. Their insights and recommendations can be invaluable in guiding your decision.
  • Maintenance Readiness: Consider your willingness and ability to perform regular maintenance. If you prefer a low-maintenance solution, Hardie Siding may be more suitable despite its higher initial cost.
  • Climate Suitability: Assess the climate in your area and choose the siding that offers the best protection and longevity under those conditions.
  • Long-Term Investment: Think about the long-term benefits and potential resale value. While initial costs are important, the overall return on investment should guide your final decision.

🙌 Choosing the Best Siding for Your Home

Choosing between LP Smartside and Hardie Siding ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. LP Smartside offers a natural wood appearance, ease of installation, and a lower upfront cost, making it an ideal choice for those who appreciate versatility and don’t mind regular maintenance. Conversely, Hardie Siding provides unmatched durability, minimal maintenance, and superior resistance to extreme weather conditions, making it a better investment for long-term home protection and value enhancement.

Before making a decision, consult with siding professionals and consider factors such as your local climate, long-term maintenance capabilities, and overall budget. We at Voyager Exteriors pride ourselves on providing exceptional roofing and siding solutions tailored to your unique needs. Our experienced team can help you navigate the decision-making process and select the best option for your home, ensuring it remains beautiful, well-protected, and valuable for years to come. Ready to transform your home’s exterior? Contact us at Voyager Exteriors today and let’s get started on your next project!

Check Out Our Recent Blog Posts

get the knowledge you need to start your home's transformation

Mother and Son Playing

Transforming Twin Cities Homes

The Voyager family can’t wait to help yours!

Get In Touch
Share to...