When it comes to siding options for your home, LP Smartside and Hardie siding are two names that frequently pop up. Both offer unique benefits and have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve into:
- What LP Smartside and Hardie siding are
- Their pros and cons
- Cost factors, climate considerations, installation, warranties
- Why we prefer James Hardie
- Signs indicating the need for siding replacement
- Guidance on choosing the right option for your home
When it comes to LP Smartside vs. Hardie board siding, what will be the right choice for you?
LP Smartside vs Hardie Siding
What is LP Smartside?
LP Smartside is an engineered wood siding product manufactured by Louisiana-Pacific Corporation (LP). It’s composed of wood strands or fibers bonded together with resin and coated with a protective overlay. This innovative siding material aims to combine the natural beauty of wood with enhanced durability and resistance to weather elements.
What is James Hardie Siding?
James Hardie siding, also known as Hardie board or HardiePlank siding, is a fiber cement siding product developed by James Hardie Industries. It’s made from a mixture of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, creating a durable and robust siding material. Hardie siding is renowned for its ability to withstand harsh weather conditions, including moisture, heat, and freezing temperatures.
Pros and Cons of Each Siding Brand
Each brand has a loyal fanbase, but what are the benefits and drawbacks to LP smartside siding and James Hardie fiber cement siding? We’ve got all the details down below:
LP Smartside:
LP Smartside siding has a long history with many pros and cons.
✅ Pros:
- Aesthetic Appeal: LP Smartside offers the authentic look of real wood, providing a warm and inviting appearance to your home’s exterior.
- Lightweight: Compared to some other siding materials, LP Smartside is relatively lightweight, making it easier to handle during installation.
- Versatility: It comes in various styles, textures, and colors, providing homeowners with a range of design options to suit their preferences.
- Cost-Effective: LP Smartside tends to be more affordable upfront compared to some alternative siding materials like Hardie.
❌ Cons:
- Vulnerability to Moisture: Despite efforts to enhance moisture resistance, LP Smartside can still be susceptible to moisture-related issues such as swelling, warping, and rotting if not properly maintained.
- Requires Regular Maintenance: It needs periodic painting or staining to maintain its appearance and protect against weather damage.
- Limited Warranty: LP Smartside typically comes with a warranty, but it may not offer the same level of protection or longevity as Hardie siding warranties.
James Hardie Siding
James Hardie siding is hugely important in the siding industry. Here’s why so many professionals choose it:
✅ Pros:
- Exceptional Durability: Hardie siding is renowned for its durability and ability to withstand a wide range of environmental conditions, including moisture, fire, and pests.
- Low Maintenance: Unlike wood siding, Hardie board requires minimal maintenance, typically only needing occasional cleaning to maintain its appearance.
- Longevity: Hardie siding is known for its longevity, often lasting several decades without needing replacement.
- Fire Resistance: It’s non-combustible, providing an added layer of fire protection to your home.
❌ Cons:
- Higher Initial Cost: James Hardie siding tends to have a higher upfront cost compared to some other siding options, including LP Smartside.
- Heavier: Due to its composition, Hardie siding is heavier than LP Smartside, which may require more effort during installation.
Cost Comparison
Hardie Siding Cost: Hardie Siding tends to have a higher initial cost due to its fiber cement composition and the need for specialized installation. However, its durability and low maintenance requirements can offset these initial expenses. The longer lifespan and minimal upkeep can make Hardie Siding a cost-effective investment in the long run.
LP Smartside Cost: LP Smartside is generally more affordable upfront than Hardie Siding. The lower cost of materials, coupled with easier installation, can make it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. However, long-term maintenance costs should be considered, as regular painting and potential repairs can add up over time.
Installation Process
Hardie Siding Installation: Hardie Siding’s fiber cement composition makes it heavier and more challenging to work with compared to engineered wood. Installation typically requires specialized tools and expertise, potentially increasing labor costs and time. However, professional installation ensures that the siding’s durability and performance are maximized.
LP Smartside Installation: LP Smartside is lighter and easier to cut than fiber cement, making the installation process relatively straightforward. It can be worked with standard woodworking tools, which can reduce labor costs and installation time. However, precise installation is vital to avoid moisture intrusion and ensure longevity.
Environmental Impact
Hardie Siding Environmental Impact: Hardie Siding is made from sustainable raw materials, including cement and cellulose fibers. Its long lifespan and low maintenance requirements contribute to a lower environmental footprint. Additionally, James Hardie has committed to environmentally friendly manufacturing processes, further enhancing the product’s sustainability.
LP Smartside Environmental Impact: LP Smartside is made from renewable wood resources, and the manufacturing process incorporates sustainable practices. The product’s longevity and durability also contribute to its environmental credentials. However, the need for regular maintenance and repainting may slightly offset these benefits.
Warranty and Support
Hardie Siding Warranty: Hardie Siding comes with a 30-year non-prorated warranty, which provides comprehensive coverage for defects in materials and workmanship. The ColorPlus Technology finish is also backed by a 15-year limited warranty against chipping, peeling, and fading. These robust warranties provide homeowners with significant peace of mind.
LP Smartside Warranty: LP Smartside offers a limited warranty of up to 50 years, reflecting the company’s confidence in the product’s durability. This warranty covers manufacturing defects and is prorated over time. Proper installation and maintenance are necessary to uphold the warranty terms.
Climate Considerations
Hardie Siding in Various Climates: Hardie Siding’s fiber cement composition makes it an excellent choice for harsh climates, including areas with extreme heat, cold, or humidity. Its resistance to fire, pests, and rot ensures reliable performance in diverse weather conditions. Homeowners in coastal areas also benefit from Hardie’s resistance to salt air corrosion.
LP Smartside in Various Climates: LP Smartside performs well in a variety of climates, but it’s particularly suited for regions with moderate weather conditions. In areas with high humidity or frequent rainfall, extra care must be taken during installation to prevent moisture-related issues. Regular maintenance is crucial in such environments to ensure long-term performance.
Why We Prefer James Hardie Siding
At Voyager, we prefer James Hardie siding for several reasons. First and foremost is its unmatched durability and longevity. Hardie siding offers homeowners peace of mind knowing that their investment will withstand the test of time and protect their home against various elements.
Additionally, the low maintenance requirements of Hardie siding make it a practical and hassle-free choice for busy homeowners. Lastly, the extensive warranty coverage provided by James Hardie Industries further reinforces our confidence in the product’s quality and reliability.
Signs That You Need to Replace Your Siding
- Visible Damage: Cracks, warping, rotting, or holes in your siding are clear signs that it’s time for a replacement.
- Increased Utility Bills: Poorly performing siding can result in energy loss, leading to higher heating and cooling bills.
- Mold or Mildew Growth: Excessive moisture buildup behind your siding can lead to mold or mildew growth, indicating a need for replacement.
- Faded Appearance: Faded or discolored siding can detract from your home’s curb appeal and may indicate underlying issues with the siding material.
How to Choose the Right Siding Material for You
Clearly, there are lot of factors to consider when it comes to choosing new siding materials for your home. Here are some questions to help you choose the right option for your lifestyle:
- Consider Your Budget: Determine how much you’re willing to invest in your siding project and weigh the upfront cost against long-term maintenance expenses.
- Evaluate Your Home’s Needs: Assess factors such as climate, architectural style, and desired aesthetic to choose a siding material that best suits your home.
- Research Installation Requirements: Different siding materials may have specific installation requirements or recommendations, so it’s essential to consider the installation process and any associated costs.
- Review Warranty Coverage: Compare the warranty coverage offered by different siding manufacturers to ensure you’re getting adequate protection for your investment.
Your Local Siding Installer
In the LP Smartside vs Hardie siding debate, both options offer unique benefits and considerations. While LP Smartside provides the natural beauty of wood at a more affordable price point, James Hardie siding stands out for its unmatched durability, low maintenance requirements, and extensive warranty coverage.
Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on your budget, preferences, and specific needs. By carefully weighing the pros and cons and considering key factors, you can select the right siding option to enhance your home’s exterior and provide long-lasting protection for years to come. Need a professional opinion? Contact Voyager Exteriors today to learn more about our siding installation services.
